Today a reader takes control of the GYFG keyboard and shares his experience investing in real estate through various platforms, including my favorite PeerStreet (my $80,000 portfolio will be revealed in about two weeks). RadCrowd as he goes by online, has some great takeaways, so be sure to read entire post.
My journey into real estate crowdfunding began over a year ago when I started to explore opportunities for passive income. I had come off a tough week at my work-a-day job as a physician and came to the realization that continuing at my current pace was resulting in burnout.
Instead of trading my time for dollars, I really needed my dollars to start working harder for me. I began to investigate real estate investing as a source of passive income; I spent hundreds of hours reading and listening to podcasts about single family, multifamily, hard money lending, notes, turnkey rentals, land, house flipping, and wholesaling.
During my research, I came to the realization that all the big boys played in the commercial real estate sandbox. Real estate syndication and hard money lending have been in existence for a long time, but these deals were limited to ultra-high net worth individuals or family and friends of the sponsor.
The JOBS act in 2012 was a game changer and opened commercial real estate to the masses through crowdfunding. Subsequently, a large number of online crowdfunding platforms have proliferated. Currently, most platforms require accredited investor status and the investments come in the form of debt or equity offerings.
For my first crowdfunding experiment, I chose PeerStreet. They offer debt investments for minimums as low as $1000. These deals are essentially hard money loans made to fix and flippers and smaller developers. Signup was easy. I set up ACH and funded the platform within one week.
I invested $20,000 split equally between four properties; two in Sacramento, one in Washington DC, and one in Los Angeles at annualized rates of 9.5% to 10%. Two have fully cycled and paid off as expected; the other two are in progress. One of the properties almost went into foreclosure but paid off in the end. Another had a couple late payments.
PeerStreet provides the property BPO and/or appraisal, as well as the borrower’s credit score for the investor’s due diligence. There is an automated investing feature where the investor can set parameters for interest rate, LTV, loan term, and amount to invest. This is almost a necessity because the best deals fill completely in hours.
This feature does allow you to cancel the deal within 24 hours if you choose. Overall, my experience with PeerStreet has been excellent. They claim no investor principal loss to date. However, interest rates have come down in the past year and are hovering around 7-9%. Deal flow has also slowed a bit as presumably more investor demand is keeping the supply side low.
Some borrowers may make late payments and the occasional loan may default. However, if a loan has a conservative loan-to-value (LTV) and the property falls into foreclosure, there is a relatively good chance that the investor will have their principal returned.
RealtyShares offers both debt and equity offerings for as low as $2000. I placed $10,000 into a commercial debt deal which funded a land purchase and ground up development of a Checker’s Restaurant. The sponsors had successfully exited other previous similar deals on the RS platform. The terms were for one year at 9.5% annualized rate. This deal exited uneventfully at the eight months mark and all principal plus interest were returned.
For equity deals, RS serves as a middleman, forming a LLC which then invests in the sponsor property. The investor owns interest in the RS LLC. This extra layer between the investor and sponsor inherently results in some opaqueness of information and communication. In addition, there is an extra layer of fees.
For this fee, I would expect a higher level of due diligence and investor protection but I don’t necessarily see this as the case. Several investors I’ve spoken to have complained about RS lack of oversight during project development, and when things go wrong, RS is slow to act and there is limited communication with the investor. K-1 errors have also been reported and brought to their attention.
Now some of this may be growing pains for a new company but for me, there are simply better platforms, deals, and sponsors to place my money with. I probably won’t be investing through RealtyShares in the future. The consensus among most members of my investment group is to leave RS once they exit their remaining deals. That being said, one of the main pluses going for RealtyShares is the relatively lower minimums.
RealCrowd (RC) and Crowdstreet (CS)
Both RealCrowd and Crowdstreet are my go-to platforms and operate similar business models; they both curate and list institutional quality commercial real estate projects from larger and more experienced sponsors.
Their selected offerings (both funds and individual deals) have passed their in-house rigorous due diligence before being presented to the accredited investor. The investor invests directly with the sponsor but can see all their investment documents and updates on the platform dashboard. For this service, RC and CS collect a fee from the sponsors. One drawback of both of these platforms is the minimums are significantly higher, ranging from 25k to 100k.
Currently I am in two investments with RealCrowd. The first is a 30k investment in a value-add multifamily apartment deal in Los Angeles with a projected IRR of 22% over a 5-year hold. The second is a 100k investment in a large $100 million fund which invests in multifamily, office, and retail with a projected IRR of 14-17% over a 6-8 year hold.
The fund has a capital call structure where not all of the money is called at once. As the fund acquires properties over a two to three-year period, they call their investors for portions of the funds as needed up to the total committed amount. By year three, all the committed capital should be called and deployed.
On Crowdstreet, I am in three investments. One is a 50k investment in a fund which invests in distressed tenant-in-common (TIC) deals, rescue capital, bridge loans, recapitalization, and other opportunistic deals. The projected IRR is 30% over a 3-year hold. The second is a 50k investment in a fund which purchases industrial flex warehouses (think Amazon warehouse and distribution center).
The projected IRR is 15% over a 5-year hold. The third is a 50k investment in a fund which invests in multifamily, office, retail, and hospitality. This fund invests at the general partner (GP) level, (as opposed to the limited partner level), which should earn higher returns if the investments do well. The projected IRR is 20-23% over a 5 year hold.
It’s too early to tell how these investments will pan out. Most of the funds are currently in the acquisition phase so there is little cash on cash return. In future years as the properties get stabilized and leased up, I expect to see higher annual returns up to the final exit event.
Of the two platforms, I favor Crowdstreet for their better customer service, larger deal selection, and offering webinars.
Here are some takeaways from my experience so far:
1) Sponsor quality is far more important than the actual deal itself. Spend the time to speak with the sponsors and get comfortable with their culture and philosophy of investing. Invest with more tenured sponsors who have seen a downturn or two.
2) Educate yourself before pulling the trigger. Learn the language for each asset type. The best way to learn the lingo is to listen to the offering webinars. Practice analyzing as many deals as you can, even if you don’t plan to invest in them.
3) Know your comfort zone. Different asset types have different risk profiles. This can range from relatively conservative (debt and Triple Net Lease) to risky (development).
4) Invest with the market cycle in mind. We may be in the late innings of the current real estate cycle as CAP rates are getting compressed in some markets. Because of this, I’m shifting towards more recession resistant assets like self-storage facilities and mobile home parks.
5) The real estate crowdfunding ecosystem is maturing. The field of hundreds of sites is being whittled down to about a dozen or so major players. Since these platforms live and die by deal volume, they are incentivized to keep pumping out deals at the expense of higher risk and poorer deal quality.
6) Don’t do this alone. Join an investor group and talk to like-minded people.
7) Most sponsors and platforms will accept retirement funds. You can use a self-directed IRA or 401k to invest in commercial real estate deals.
Real estate crowdfunding is a novel investment vehicle and may have a place in a well-diversified portfolio. Accredited investors now have unprecedented access to commercial real estate deal flow not available before; however, care must be taken to mitigate risk. These investments are not for everyone; do your due diligence and invest with experienced, high quality sponsors.
IIIIInteresting. Thanks for doing a review of these different platforms. I’m intrigued in real estate crowdfunding, but it’s so new that I’m still looking for more info on its returns.
Thanks for reading Mrs. Picky Pincher. The crowdfunding space is continuing to evolve. The returns can be high, but watch out for risk. The real test will be to see who is left standing when the next downturn comes. Best of luck with your investing!
RadCrowd – Thanks a lot for sharing your experience so far with other platforms.
I look forward to hopefully hearing periodic updates from you. I will be publishing the details into my PeerStreet portfolio on Monday. It really is nice to be able to invest using these platforms and not have to deal with the management side of real estate…all the reward with none of the hassle.
Thank you Rad Crowd. I hope all goes well with your investments. I recently invested on Peer Street, Equity Multiple, and Real Crowd as well. If I had discovered Equity Multiple earlier, I probably would allocate more to them. Their team seems excellent so far in every way.
Thanks Petey Pete. I’m glad Equity Multiple is working out for you. I’ve also heard good things about them from other investors. I looked into them several months ago.
Unfortunately they don’t accept self directed IRA money so that kept me out. Also when I last checked there were no open investments so deal flow is somewhat limited. Maybe it’s good they are being picky? Good luck with your investing.
“The real test will be to see who is left standing when the next downturn comes. ”
This is the exact sentiment I discussed with a funding colleague here in the UK. Our area is financing the development of property, from refurbish to new build.
The industry has seen a huge influx of money in recent years at, in our view, risky loan to values. It’s ok in a rising market but when lending decisions rely on increases, rather than skilled under writing, it’s a recipe for disaster!
On a side note, one of the largest players in our market recently pulled out of real estate, even though they reported that their projects were profitable.
To me, it suggests some providers don’t know what they are getting into when it comes to managing project loan books. I suggest being incredibly careful when backing a build project. You really need to be sure the lender, not just the borrower, know what they are doing!